Indiana does not have a statute that writes the appraisal process for homeowners and commercial property policies. Your rights come from the appraisal condition in your own policy, read together with Indiana contract law. The wording varies by carrier, so treat this guide as a map of how appraisal commonly runs, then check each step against your policy.
1. Confirm it is an amount dispute
Appraisal resolves how much a covered loss costs. Before anything else, confirm the carrier has accepted coverage for at least part of the loss and that the disagreement is about scope or price, not whether the policy applies.
2. Read the clause and the calendar
Find the appraisal condition in your policy, note how long each side has to name an appraiser, and calendar the suit-limitation date. Appraisal may not stop that clock.
3. Send the written demand
Either side can demand appraisal in writing. The demand identifies the claim, states that the parties disagree on the amount of loss and names your appraiser or commits to naming one within the policy window.
4. Both appraisers inspect and estimate
Each appraiser inspects the property and builds or refines a line-item estimate. Good appraisers document measurements, photos and pricing sources for every disputed line.
5. Appraisers negotiate line by line
The two appraisers compare estimates item by item. Many disputes narrow sharply here, and an agreed award signed by both appraisers ends the process.
6. The umpire decides what is left
Items the appraisers can’t agree on go to the umpire they selected, or one appointed by a court if they couldn’t agree. The umpire reviews submissions, may inspect, and decides each item.
7. Sign the award and get paid
An award signed by any two of the three panel members sets the amount of loss. The carrier then applies the deductible, depreciation and limits and issues payment under the policy.
How long it takes
A residential file with a clear scope often wraps up in two to three months after both appraisers are named. Large commercial losses, contents-heavy claims and files that need an umpire hearing can take longer. Delays most often come from incomplete documentation, so the work you do before the demand pays off later.
What it costs
Each side pays its own appraiser, and most policies split the umpire’s fee equally. Appraiser fees may be a flat amount, hourly or a percentage of the increase. Get the arrangement in writing before anyone starts, and run your numbers through the claim gap and net recovery estimator.
Where appraisal stops
An appraisal panel values the loss. It doesn’t decide coverage, interpret disputed policy language beyond what valuation requires, or award damages for bad faith. Indiana courts recognize that insurers owe policyholders a duty of good faith and fair dealing, and the state’s unfair claim settlement practices law is enforced by the Indiana Department of Insurance. Whether a particular claim was mishandled is a legal question for an Indiana attorney.
