What an estimate review is
An insurance estimate review is a focused professional read of the carrier’s estimate compared with the damage, your photos and any contractor quote. It’s the most economical way to learn whether you have a real dispute and how big it is.
What we check
- Scope: rooms, elevations, slopes and trades that were missed or shortened.
- Measurements: square footage, roof squares, linear footage of trim and gutters.
- Pricing: unit costs compared with current pricing for your Indiana market.
- Labor minimums and small-job charges that apply to trades with only a little work.
- Overhead and profit where a general contractor is reasonably needed to coordinate multiple trades.
- Depreciation: whether ages and useful lives make sense and whether labor was depreciated in a way your policy allows.
- Code items and permits required by your local building department.
What you get
A written summary that lists the major gaps in plain language, a rough dollar range and our honest recommendation. Sometimes that recommendation is to send the carrier a documented supplement request rather than invoke appraisal. Sometimes it’s that the carrier’s number is fair and appraisal would cost more than it could recover.
When to request a review
The best time is after you receive the carrier’s estimate and before you sign any release or accept a final payment. If you have already received a payment, a review can still help with recoverable depreciation and supplements, as long as policy deadlines haven’t passed.
Frequently asked questions
How much does an estimate review cost?
We quote a flat fee in writing before starting, based on the size of the claim. The first conversation is free.
Will you contact my insurance company?
Not as part of a review. You decide what to do with the findings. If you later retain us as your appraiser, we communicate within the appraisal process.
My contractor already wrote a supplement. Do I still need a review?
Not always. A review is most useful when the contractor’s supplement has been rejected or when the gap is large enough that appraisal is on the table.
