Hail in Indiana is routine, which is why carriers scrutinize it
Thunderstorms crossing the state from the west regularly drop hail between an inch and two inches across central Indiana, the Wabash Valley and the northern tier. Because hail is so common here, carriers look closely for prior damage, wear and “cosmetic only” arguments. A strong roof claim answers those questions before they are asked.
How we document a hail-damaged roof
- Test squares on every slope, marked and photographed, with hit counts that show the pattern of damage by direction.
- Soft metals: dents in gutters, downspouts, vents, flashing and AC fins that confirm hail size and direction.
- Collateral checks on siding, window wraps, screens and fencing that corroborate the storm.
- Storm date research using public weather reports so the damage ties to a specific event within your policy period.
- Accurate measurements, including pitch, waste and the steep or high charges estimating software applies.
Partial repair or full replacement?
This is the most common roof dispute we see. A carrier may approve a few slopes or a set number of shingles while the rest of the roof shows the same damage. Add discontinued shingle lines, brittle older shingles that tear when lifted, and color mismatches, and a spot repair can leave an Indiana homeowner with a roof that is neither whole nor uniform. Whether your policy requires matching depends on its wording; we document the facts that matter to that question.
Line items that disappear
Drip edge, ice and water shield in valleys and at eaves (required by many Indiana jurisdictions in northern counties), starter strip, ridge vent, pipe jacks, permits and code-required underlayment are often missing or underpriced. We check every component a roofer would actually install.
Frequently asked questions
The adjuster called it cosmetic. Is that the end?
Not necessarily. Some policies include cosmetic damage exclusions for metal roofing or siding; many don’t. Whether bruised shingles are functional damage is a factual question appraisal panels deal with routinely.
My roof is 15 years old. Will that hurt my claim?
Age affects depreciation on an actual cash value basis, and carriers may argue prior wear. Clear storm-specific evidence like fresh hits on soft metals helps separate new damage from old.
How long do I have to file a hail claim?
Your policy requires prompt notice and may set a firm window. Report as soon as you notice damage; waiting through another storm season complicates proof.
