Using the estimator
- Enter the insurer’s RCV total, the replacement cost figure before depreciation and the deductible.
- Enter your own RCV estimate from a contractor or independent estimator.
- Set your best guess on the slider, then compare it with the cautious, middle and strong scenarios.
- Add fees using your appraiser’s quoted arrangement and a realistic umpire figure.
Read the cautious scenario first
Panels rarely award either side’s opening number in full. Well-supported line items tend to survive and unsupported ones tend to fall away. If your net only looks good in the strong scenario, the file may need more documentation before you demand appraisal. If the cautious scenario still leaves you ahead, appraisal is more likely to be worthwhile.
What this tool doesn’t include
Depreciation timing, deductibles and policy limits change what you are paid, not the size of the dispute. For the payment split, use the RCV/ACV holdback calculator. All figures are illustrative.
Questions about this tool
Is the projected award a prediction?
No. It is a planning scenario based on numbers you choose. Actual awards depend on documentation, the panel and your policy.
What do umpires typically charge?
Umpire fees vary with the size and complexity of the dispute. Ask for a quote when an umpire is proposed; most policies split the cost evenly.
